Your shed’s foundation determines the structural integrity of the whole structure. If the shed’s foundation is still sound, then repairing the other damages to the shed is favorable. When the foundation is sturdy, it will be easier to repair the shed without having to worry about the structure warping or sinking.
Shed Repairs vs. Shed Removals
Jon Lantz • October 29, 2025
Sheds often need repairs, especially after a particularly rainy or snowy season in New Jersey. A shed from Jed’s Sheds is built with the highest-quality materials, but after a few years of use, it will need to be repaired. Sometimes, your old shed may not be worth the repairs that are needed, and it’s best to remove it and invest in a new one. If shed repairs or removals are not completed as soon as they’re needed, then the belongings inside can be damaged as well. To help you understand the difference, below we have outlined when to repair and when to remove your shed.
When to Repair Your Shed
Repairs are Minor
Repairing your shed is favorable when the damage is minor and can be fixed yourself or by a contractor. Things like small cracks or holes in the walls, broken roof shingles, and uneven floors are minor damages that can easily be repaired. You could also repair things like a leaky roof, broken windows, and damaged siding and trim at home. If repairs are too difficult to complete yourself, we recommend enlisting the help of a professional contractor at Jed’s Sheds to repair larger issues. If your roof is too damaged to repair, we can replace just the roof of your shed to extend its lifespan.
Repairs are Affordable
Shed repairs often range in cost, depending on how minor or major the needed repairs are. If the cost of repairing the shed is affordable, then we’ve found it best to give it a few extra years of life before building a new one. Generally, for simpler repairs, the costs are significantly less than replacing your shed. Repairs like replacing door hinges and locks, fixing shingles, and repainting are inexpensive. Oftentimes, shed repairs are the more cost-effective option.
Shed has a Solid Foundation
When to Remove and Buy New
Repairing is Too Expensive
When the cost to repair your shed starts to become close to the price of removing and buying a new one, we recommend investing in the new one. If the shed needs so many repairs that the cost is expensive, then it might be telling you that the shed is too old to repair. Severe damage is costly to repair, so start fresh by investing in a new shed. The money you would spend on repairs can go towards this new, more durable shedfrom Jed’s Sheds.
Structural Damage
If the foundation or the structural integrity of the shed is extremely damaged or rotting, then it’s best to remove the shed and replace it. The foundation is the support for the whole structure, if it’s damaged, it can lead to other issues. Look for signs of rot, deterioration, sinking, cracks, and water damage in the walls, roof, and framing, to determine the stability of the structure and its foundation. New Jersey’s heavy rain and snow can cause moisture to get into the shed, deteriorating the structure over time. In our experience, foundational damage is difficult and costly to repair, so it’s better to just replace the whole shed.
Safety Risks
Sometimes, an old or damaged shed can have too many safety risks to properly work inside it. A shed from Jed’s Sheds can last around 20 years, but old age, mold, and pest infestations can deter you from safely working in your shed.
Widespread Mold
Our vinyl sheds are more resistant to mold, but a wooden painted shed can have more moisture buildup inside, leading to widespread mold growth. A few patches of mold can easily be cleaned and removed from the shed. However, if the mold has spread throughout the shed, it may be more efficient to remove and replace it. Widespread mold will be very difficult to completely remove and might not guarantee that mold won’t continue to grow, so replacing the shed is the best way to start clean again.
Pest Infestation
Pests may cause irreparable damage to your shed. If they’ve made a home of your shed, they could damage the materials inside. Common pests you can find in your shed in New Jersey are mice, squirrels, bees, cockroaches, termites, and more. You can take steps to deter pests from getting into your shed, but if there’s an infestation, the damage they cause, especially from termites, may call for a shed replacement.
You Need More Space
Sometimes, a shed could be in good condition, but it doesn’t meet your storage needs anymore. Your shed may also be outdated or the styling doesn’t match your personality anymore. You may have accumulated a lot of things for your shed, and even after decluttering, you may notice you don’t have enough space anymore. If you realize you need more storage space, we recommend replacing your shed with a larger one. Build a larger model to comfortably organize everything inside your shed.,
Jed’s Sheds Repair and Removal Services
At Jed’s Sheds, we offer additional shed services, including site preparation, relocation, ramp installations, and shed repairs and removals. Our team can help you repair your shed’s roof, trim, doors and windows, and siding to prolong the shed’s lifespan. When your shed is too old or damaged to repair, we can remove the old shed properly and replace it with a new, durable one that will last around 20 years. If you’re looking for a new shed, check out our in-stock inventory of styles ready for delivery, or design a custom shed with our 3D Builder. Contact us today to get started.
With recent rainfalls in New Jersey, learn how to weatherproof your shed with Jed's Sheds. Build a durable, custom shed today.
A guest house is a great addition to your property for a space for your family and friends. Learn how to turn a detached garage into a guest house with Jed's Sheds.